Whoa, Momma! | Tampa Bay Moms | Who controls a pregnant woman's body -- her or her doctors?
Posted Jan 28 2010 8:36pm
The question is one you hear all the time during debates over abortion: Who controls a pregnant woman's body? Under current law, a woman has the right to make her own decisions about what happens to her body and her baby, right? Surely even Tim Tebow would agree with that, right?
But that's not how a judge in Tallahassee saw it, according to the this story.
Samantha Burton went to a hospital 25 weeks into her pregnancy and was admitted into Tallahassee Memorial Hospital because of complications. Her doctor -- also a woman -- ordered her to immediately quit smoking and stay in the hospital on complete bed rest for the remainder of her pregnancy. Burton disagreed. She wanted to go to a different hospital and get a second opinion.
During the court hearing, Burton had no attorney. She had to try to argue her case over the phone from her hospital bed. Circuit Judge John Cooper decided it was in the best interest of the child for her to remain at the hospital on bed rest. The judge didn't trust her to not smoke or care for herself and the baby.
There is no happy ending here, no bouncing baby who turned out healthy because of the court's actions. Three days after the judge committed her to the hospital, Burton underwent an emergency Cesarean section. Her baby was stillborn.
Now, six months later, Burton has an attorney (handling her case for free) and she's appealing the judge's ruling. Her attorney, David H. Abrams, says his client doesn't want money. She wants to be sure her case doesn't set precedent for other mothers who may someday wind up in the same boat…