“If all consumers exercised, did what they had to do, the problem of obesity wouldn’t exist.”
Really? Obesity levels have exponentially increased over the past three decades, but gym memberships haven’t taken a sudden plunge. Similarly, surveys and polls don’t show that Americans are exercising any less today than they were in the ’80s or ’90s; quite the opposite, actually!
This is the basic “personal responsibility” argument on steroids. It surpasses the usual “well, our foods aren’t meant to be eaten all the time” message to now completely discredit nutritional approaches to obesity. Apparently, chips and soda every day are a-okay as long as you hit the treadmill (for, what, six hours?).
Ms. Nooyi also falls prey to the fallacy that health is only about weight. One can be at a healthy weight but subsist on highly-processed, minimally-nutritious junk that increases blood pressure and heart disease risk, to name a few conditions.
“If I look at our portfolio, I think you can classify them into three groups: “fun-for-you foods” like Pepsi, Doritos, Lays, and Mountain Dew, “better-for-you” products like Diet Pepsi, PepsiMax, Baked Lays, Sobi Life Water, Propel, all of these products, and “good-for-you” products like Quaker, Tropicana, Naked Juice, Gatorade.”
“Fun-for-you foods”? I understand she’s not going to bash her own product line, but why not call a spade a “kinda-sorta” spade and at the classify those foods as “occasional treats”? Besides, we all know there is nothing “fun” about your breath after you eat a few Cool Ranch Doritos.
Diet soda a “better-for-you” product? News to me! An absence of calories and sugar does not automatically make a food healthier, especially when the calories and sugar are replaced with a long list of chemicals (most of which have no studies demonstrating that long-term consumption is safe).
Referring to Quaker and Gatorade as “good-for-you” is also a stretch. Gatorade is essentially sugar water (its electrolyte values are a joke), and while the Quaker line does include straight-up, unsweetened oatmeal, many of their products contain a hefty amount of added sugars. The mere presence of oats does not make a product healthy, especially if the oats are accompanied by sweeteners and/or oils loaded with omega-6 fatty acids.
“The longevity in parts of China is very, very high because there’s a lot of traditional Chinese medicine that is based on herbs that really help lifestyle management, that really help body mass index down, that really help the longevity of the person.”
You know why else longevity in certain parts of China is very high? Residents eat whole, unprocessed foods. They aren’t munching on “fun-for-you” foods like Doritos or chugging 20-ounce bottles of sugar water with a pinch of potassium Gatorade.
Herbs that help keep body mass index down? Wait a minute, didn’t she just say that the only way to not be obese was by exercising?
I’m also surprised and disappointed that someone of Asian heritage would play into the stereotypical exoticization of East Asian cultures (”they don’t stay healthy just by watching what they eat, they also ingest magic and secret herbs!”)
“Now, I’m not talking about “pixie dust.” I’m talking about real science-based stuff.”
Ah, of course, the ever-popular “herbs aren’t REAL science” argument. Long live narrow-mindedness! You would think that if Ms. Nooyi was such a “real science” buff, she would have some appreciation for nutrition science and acknowledge its importance in weight management.