See my interview with Dr. Erika Schwartz where we discussed this issue. It would also as a nice side effect to save some horses too while we are at it if in fact the bioidentical drugs are shown to be safer.
“Dr. Schwartz named several FDA-approved drugs that are bio identical to include Estrace, Evamist, Vagifem, Estraderm, and Climara for estrogen and Prochieve, Prometrium, and Crinone for progesterone.”
In the interview, Dr. Erika and I talked about the lack of studies that compare Premarin to Bio identical Hormones. Also I noticed in this article that there was no mention of FDA approved Bio Identical hormone therapy. I know it has been very controversial with personalized compounding, but what about running some numbers comparing Premarin against the names listed above that are Bio Identical and approved by the FDA?
Where’s the numbers? Could Harvard crank out a study for us? Why do we not talk about the Bio Identical Treatments that “are” approved by the FDA is my question.
Here’s a news video from the past about the horses that are used to create the drug. The horses are not getting a good deal here either. BD
MILLIONS of American women in the 1990s were told they could help their bodies ward off major illness by taking menopausal hormone drugs. Some medical associations said so. Many gynecologists and physicians said so. Respected medical journals said so, too.
Now Ms. Barton, who said in an interview that she used Prempro in part because her doctor told her it could help prevent heart disease and dementia, is one of more than 13,000 people who have sued Wyeth over the last seven years, claiming in courts across the country that its menopause drugs caused breast cancer and other problems.
The suits also assert, based on recently unsealed court documents, that Wyeth oversold the benefits of menopausal hormones and failed to properly warn of the risks.
Mr. Loder also notes that Pfizer plans to appeal every product-liability case on menopausal drugs it loses, including Ms. Barton’s.
But Dr. Shuster of the Mayo Clinic says the hormones have not been extensively studied for safety and efficacy. And, unlike branded hormone therapy, she says, they have not been approved by the F.D.A.
Women, Dr. Shuster says, should not assume that compounded hormones are safer than F.D.A.-approved menopausal hormone drugs. Nevertheless, with sales of more than two million books, Ms. Somers has become a menopause guru to millions.
“I think I had a lot to do with making the word ‘menopause’ mentionable,” Ms. Somers, 63, said in a phone interview last week. She said the compounded hormones were safe, and she sent some articles from medical journals to back up her point.