MMRV Doubles Risk for Febrile Seizures 7 to 10 Days After Vaccination
Posted Jul 11 2010 12:00am
From MedscapeCME Clinical Briefs
News Author: Pauline Anderson CME Author: Charles P. Vega, MD
June 30, 2010 — Infants aged 12 to 23 months have about double the risk of developing a febrile seizure for 7 to 10 days after being vaccinated with the measles-mumps-rubella-varicella (MMRV) combination vaccine compared with those receiving separate MMR and varicella vaccines, according to a new study.
Despite this increase, physicians and parents should understand that the overall risk for febrile seizures from either the MMR or MMRV vaccine is low, stressed lead study author Nicola P. Klein, MD, PhD, codirector of the Kaiser Permanente Vaccine Study Center in Oakland, California.
"The risk is less than 1 per 1000 doses, but the risk is twice as much for febrile seizures for MMRV when you compare it with MMR and varicella," Dr. Klein said. "The MMRV will cause 1 additional febrile seizure for every 2300 doses of MMRV given instead of the separate vaccine.”
The study appears in the July 2010 issue of Pediatrics and was published online June 28.
Double the Data
For the study, researchers used electronic health records from the Vaccine Safety Datalink (VSD), a collaborative effort between the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Immunization Safety Office and 8 managed care organizations across the country. The analysis included data on 459,000 children who had been vaccinated — 83,000 with the MMRV vaccine and 376,000 with the MMR plus varicella vaccines — from 2000 to 2008.
The MMRV vaccine was licensed by the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in 2005. Shortly after that, the VSD began actively monitoring the safety of new vaccines, including the MMRV vaccine, explained Dr. Klein. Preliminary studies showed a roughly 2-fold increased rate of seizures with this combination vaccine compared with the separate vaccines — information that was reported to the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices in February 2008.
Since then, they've doubled the available data on the MMRV vaccine, said Dr. Klein. "Also, when we originally reported in 2008, we just looked at the 7 to 10 days after vaccination; since then, we've looked at the entire 42 days after vaccination and found that the febrile seizure risk is confined to just the 7- to 10-day window."
According to background information in the study, the VSD creates aggregated dynamic data sets that are updated weekly and contain vaccine information and outcomes. MMRV rapid cycle analysis surveillance monitored children 12 to 23 months old for 6 outcomes. In addition to seizures, outcomes of interest included thrombocytopenia, encephalitis or meningitis, ataxia, allergic reactions, and arthritis.
The researchers compared the cumulative number of seizures observed with the number expected on the basis of the historical VSD seizure rates from 2000 to 2006 after MMR vaccine was administered with or without varicella. They examined postvaccination outpatient fever visits for fever or febrile illness at 7 participating VSD sites from January 2000 to October 2008.
Seizures were defined according to the International Classification of Diseases, Ninth Revision. To assess whether postvaccination seizures were febrile seizures, researchers conducted medical record reviews. When available, they also captured data on previous seizure history, family history of seizures, and whether the seizure resulted in hospitalization.
For the primary analysis, as well as for 3 supplementary analyses, researchers adjusted for age group, site, calendar year, and respiratory virus season.
The study found that seizure incidence peaked during the period days 7 to 10 after vaccination with all measles-containing vaccines. Primary analysis revealed significantly higher seizure risk after MMRV vaccination than after MMR plus varicella vaccination during this time (relative risk, 1.98; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.43 – 2.73).
"What we found in our study is that when you take combination vaccine — measles, mumps, rubella, and varicella — in the combination vaccine, there's a doubling of the risk for febrile seizures when you compare them with children who received separate MMR and varicella vaccines," said Dr. Klein.
MMRV vaccination was associated with an estimated 4.3 additional seizures per 10,000 doses (95% CI, 2.6 – 5.6) during the 7 to 10 days after vaccination. This translates into about 1 additional febrile seizure for every 2300 MMRV doses administered to 12- to 23-month-olds instead of separately administered same-day MMR plus varicella vaccination.
Medical record reviews verified 94% of electronically identified seizures as acute seizures, with 87% being febrile seizures. Using case-centered analyses strengthened the results because they addressed confounding caused by coding or diagnostic practices, data error, patient demographics, or care-seeking behavior, said the study authors.
The study results "show that both MMRV and MMR vaccines, but not varicella vaccine alone, are associated with increased outpatient fever visits and seizures 7 to 10 days after vaccination, with MMRV vaccine increasing fever and seizure twice as much as the MMR plus varicella vaccines," said the study authors. "MMRV vaccine doubles an already elevated risk for febrile seizures."
Dr. Klein pointed out that febrile seizures are common but usually harmless in children. "Up to 5% of children 6 months to 5 years of age can have a febrile seizure, and they are almost always due to colds or other infections. These seizures are a benign condition and they self-resolve. They don't have any long-term side effects; they don't, for example, lead to seizures and they don't lead to epilepsy."
However, they can be alarming. "The seizures can be very frightening for parents," said Dr. Klein. "Typically, it's a full-body convulsion and so parents do bring [the] child to the emergency department."
Pediatric Academy Statement
Asked to comment on the research, John Bradley, MD, a member of the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) Committee on Infectious Disease, director of the Division of Infectious Diseases at Rady Children's Hospital, and associate clinical professor of pediatrics, University of California at San Diego, said the AAP supports both vaccines equally.
However, the increased risk for febrile seizures with the MMRV vaccine should be shared with parents. "You should then let them make the decision. If you can't communicate with them because of a language barrier or other reason, you should give the vaccines separately to minimize risks of adverse events."
Dr. Bradley agreed that some parents would still opt for the combined vaccine. "Some prefer the convenience of just coming to the doctor and getting 1 vaccine rather than 2 shots for their kids, but we want them to have that option."
He added that when the MMRV vaccine was first approved by the FDA, "we knew that there was a little bit of extra fever but at that time the repercussion of that extra fever, meaning febrile seizures, was not yet defined."
The AAP is preparing a statement on this issue, which should be released in a month, if not before, said Dr. Bradley.
Dr. Bradley reiterated that febrile seizures are usually "very brief" and benign. "They're not known to produce any neurological injury. If the seizures were horrible and children ended up with injury, we would not be recommending this vaccine."
However, they could be a burden on the healthcare system. The AAP is carrying out an analysis of the extra costs associated with visits to general practitioners and neurologists and trips to the emergency department because of vaccine-related febrile seizures, said Dr. Bradley.
It is not clear exactly why there is increased fever with the combination vaccine. It could be because this vaccine needs extra varicella virus to produce the same immune response as the separate vaccines, said Dr. Bradley.
This study was supported by the VSD contract with America's Health Insurance Plans, funded by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Dr. Klein and Roger Baxter, MD, have reported research support from Merck & Co, Novartis, GlaxoSmithKline, Wyeth, and Sanofi-Pasteur; the other study authors have disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
Pediatrics. Published online June 28, 2010. Clinical Context
The MMRV vaccine was licensed by the FDA in 2005. The combination of the MMR and varicella vaccines affords the promise of similar immune protection against important infections with a reduction in the number of injections, which young children need to endure. However, prelicensure studies of the MMRV revealed that it promoted higher rates of fever and measles-like rash in the 1 to 2 weeks after vaccination vs separate MMR and varicella vaccines.
There has also been evidence that the combined MMRV vaccine may promote a higher risk for seizures vs the separate MMR and varicella vaccines. The current study analyzes data from the VSD to address this issue.