I found this review of Richard Dawkins' review of Behe's "Edge of Evolution" very well put. Of course evolutionists will reject it because it is in the religious magazine "First Things". They likely won't consider the points Neuhaus makes. He especially questions why NYTs would choose Dawkins to do a supposed unbiased review.
I liked this.
It is hard to know what purpose is served by the Book Review in having Dawkins review Behe, except, possibly, to ostracize anyone
who presumes to raise questions about prevailing Darwinist orthodoxies
and, perhaps, to pander to the smug prejudices of the presumed
readership of the Times.