
Not to beat this issue to death, but a prestigious medical journal, the Journal of Clinical Gastroenterology, takes a much harsher view on what the author calls "colonic quackery": From J Clin Gastroenterol. 1997 Jun;24(4):196-8
Colonic irrigation and the theory of autointoxication: A triumph of ignorance over science.
Autointoxication is an ancient theory based on the belief that intestinal waste products can poison the body and are a major contributor to many, if not all, diseases. In the 19th century, it was the ruling doctrine of medicine and led "colonic quackery" in various guises. By the turn of the century, it had received some apparent backing from science. When it became clear that the scientific rationale was wrong and colonic irrigation was not merely useless but potentially dangerous, it was exposed as quackery and subsequently went into a decline. Today we are witnessing a resurgence of colonic irrigation based on little less than the old bogus claims and the impressive power of vested interests. Even today's experts on colonic irrigation can only provide theories and anecdotes in its support. It seems, therefore, that ignorance is celebrating a triumph over science.
In response to Stephanie's comment, I did a medline search for studies of the benefits and or hazards of colonic irrigation. It seems there is not a great deal of medical literature on the alternative medicine practice of colonic irrigation. There is one review of colonic irrigation in a journal that is "Pro" alternative and complementary medicine -- It documents the evidence of benefits (there is no evidence) and of possible risks (no good studies have measured how high the risks are), see J Altern Complement Med. 2006 May;12(4):389-93. The bottom line remains that the claims of benefit of colonic irrigation are anecdotes only, and there do not appear to me to be any documented benefits - but who knows what a properly designed study might show. There are at least theoretical hazards, and those hazards may be amplified if non trained and non licensed practitioners are giving the treatment.
Write a comment:
|
Colonics
Posted by Kenna M.
I just wrote an article on how to get a colonic. I have never had one, but it appears quite beneficial for those who want to clean themselves out. The benefits are reportedly amazing -- cleaner skin, more energy, better digestion and anti-aging. The therapist even discusses your diet with you as you watch the "stuff" come out. It seems like it might be little embarrassing or uncomfortable at first, but once you past that threshold, the benefits out weight the uneasiness. Have you ever tried a colonic? If so, how many have you had?