Health knowledge made personal
Join this community!
› Share page:
Search posts:

The Voice of ED

Posted Feb 14 2010 10:10am
Many people with eating disorders report a "voice" in their head that tells them to starveto bingeto purgeto exercise. This voice hisses and spits while they look in the mirror and try on clothes. It congratulates you on every pound (half-poundquarter-pound) lost. Jenni Schaefer calls her eating disordered voice "Ed," and considers it separate from herself. Ed is the voice of an eating disorderand not the voice of Jenni.

I think this can be a tremendous therapy tooland have tried it myselfexcept for one tiny detail: my eating disordered voice sounds exactly like me. I can be sitting in the car and drivingtrying to figure out how many miles I have left before my destinationwhether I should pull through the car washwhether I might need the oil changedand slide seamlessly into a diatribe of self-loathing about how much I ate and how much more I should have exercised. It sounds like me and it talks like me and it can talk for is it me?

What makes it even harder for me is the fact that I've been hearing this voicein one form or anothersince long before I ever had an eating disorder. It was the voice that told me I was a loser because I couldn't write the cute bubble letters like the other girls my age and that no one would like me. It was the voice that scolded me for not getting a perfect score on my spelling test. It was the voice that said no one would ever want to be my friendso I may as well get over it. It was the voice that told me my high school graduation honors were a matter of luck.

If I could condense down everything the voice told me into one simple phraseit would be: Nodon't. Should I go to the party? Nodon't. Should I eat that cookie? Nodon't. Should I speak up? Nodon't. Should I break out of my routine? Nodon't. Should I buy those jeans/that book/that expensive bar of chocolate? Nodon't. It's a life of "Nothank youI shouldn'tI couldn'tI would never." There are situations when this is a sensible path to take--it tends to protect personal safetyand that's not a bad thing. But when that's your lifewhen that's all you know and all you will let yourself knowit's not quite so universally positive.

I was at a get-together last night with a friend of mine. I was visiting L for the weekend (I'm sitting on her floor as I write this)and she was invited to a small party with some friends of hersand I tagged along. I had previously met almost all of the people thereand they were all really nice people. I knew that weren't judgmental or anything--that wasn't what I was worried about. I hesitated to join in on the conversation because I was afraid I would say something stupidafraid I would offend someone. Should I join in on the talk? Nodon't. It was when someone broke out the karaoke machine that I really started to shut down. I didn't know many of the songsand even when I did find a song I rememberedI knew I would never ask to sing it. I was too afraid of embarrassing myself. The other girls who were singing seemed to have quite a bit of talentand I was certain I would sound rather terrible next to them. I can't belt out lyrics- my voice just doesn't seem to go that loud. The clincher was the fact that the computer system gave you a score at the end of your song. I was certain that I wouldn't get the highest scoreand I knew that if I didn'tI would hate myself. So I didn't sing.

There was a part of me that just didn't feel like standing up and singingwhich is finebut I've never really been able to cut loosebe goofyand just have fun. I'm always thinking ahead and anticipating what might be nexthow I could look like an ass. Although these thoughts have nothing to do with food and weightthey still seem like a product of the anorexic voiceof the perennial chatter I hear in my head that seems to come from within.

Perhaps one of the hardest parts is this: it's not always mean. Sometimesthe voice is kind and reassuringlike "YesI know. It's okay. I'll do better tomorrow." The unsaid piece is that there will be hell to pay if I don't shape upbut stillI'm not berating myselfI'm encouraging myself to do betterto eat lessto exercise moreto study harder. Most of my major relapses started out this way: I started to cut back on foodand if I slipped upI gave myself a pat on the back and said that tomorrow would be a better day. As the relapse progressedthe voice became harsher and more demanding.

It turns out I'm not the only person with anorexia who has seen this progression. A recent study in Psychology and Psychotherapy asked anorexia sufferers to describe their experiences living with the "anorexic voice" and found that
These data underlined the positive and negative attributes individuals bestowed upon their anorexic voice; the former appeared stronger during the early stages of their eating disorderthe latter coming into force as it developed. In spite of their voice's harsh and forceful characterparticipants felt an affiliation towards it. The bond between individuals and their anorexic voice could explain their ambivalence to change. Therapists must persist in their endeavours to penetrate this tiewhilst acknowledging the hold this entity has over those with anorexia. Interventions that address this component of the eating disorder could prove fruitful in helping people towards recovery.
I'm not sure I have a quote-unquote "bond" with the voice in my headbut I do know I'm used to itand its presence doesn't really bother me. FurthermoreI find it hard to say for sure whether this voice is external or internal. Since it seemed familiar even at the outset of the eating disorderit feels like it's always been thereeven if I wasn't harping at my food intake and weight. It seems ultimately like a perfectionistic voice that happened to become utterly myopic about food and weight.

Do you have an ED voice? How do you experience it? In your commentsI want everyone to feel they can be open and honest; howeverI'm also aware that such discussions can be triggeringso keep that in mind as you share. Thanks!
Post a comment
Write a comment:

Related Searches