Catalog with too-thin models is voluntarily pulled
Posted Sep 01 2008 7:09pm
The Canadian clothing company, La Maison Simons, agreed to pull its new 36-page catalog after complaints from the public poured in. Their complaints? The catalog featured "photographs of thin, young women, who display more bone than flesh."
Company CEO, Peter Simons, had this to say about the catalog:
Those images are "destructive to a more vulnerable portion of the population which is exposed to anorexia," Simons told The Gazette from his office in Quebec City..."We are into social responsibility here. I'm fully aware of what it is and I'm taking full responsibility for (the catalogue). It's my job to ensure that we are a constructive actor in the community," Simons said. "I should have done better. I should have seen it."
I am happy that Simons recognized the error of his ways, and acknowledged it publically- though it would have been nice if he didn't need public complaint letters to make him do so. I think it sends a powerful message to the clothing industry that people aren't going to just sit back and take in the unrealistic images of women and men.
However, I don't know how much this will do to prevent eating disorders. The fact of the matter is that we don't know what causes eating disorders. We know it takes both a genetic predisposition and an environmental trigger to develop an eating disorder. Does living in a thin-idolizing society make things worse? Perhaps. It certainly doesn't help. But almost unknown research from the late 1990s on the island of Curacao found the rates of anorexia on a fat-is-beautiful island are essentially the same as those found in Europe and the US.
So why don't we say what we do know: this is a good thing to do regardless of its effects on eating disorders. That this kind of advertising is toxic, to women and men, regardless of their potentials of developin an eating disorder. That it doesn't need to cause a clinical disorder before becoming evil. That we don't know how to prevent eating disorders. And that eating disorders have nothing to do with fashion and "looking good."