Fibre Supplements
I started to respond to Brevin’s question about fibre supplements, but the comment was getting too long, so I figured I’d make a new post about it. I just started using fibre supplements during my last hospital stay. I hadn’t needed them before but after the incident with the blockages, I was losing way too much fluid (I had to stay in the hospital on IV), so I had to take fibre supple 
ments to slow things down.
On a bit of an educational note, if you’re looking at different brands and options, I think the key is that you need a “bulking agent”. The psyllium in Metamucil is a bulking agent, as are a few synthetic fibres (like inulin in Benefibre). In general, the synthetic fibres need smaller doses to achieve the same results. I also looked into more food-like options, such as cereals with psyllium fibre. The problem is, while the nutritional information tells you how much fibre the cereal provides, it doesn’t tell you how much psyllium fibre in particular you will get from a serving. My understanding is that this matters – not all fibres do the same thing. The bulking agents actually absorb water, but other fibres don’t. There is a useful comparison chart found at the University of Iowa Hospital website (http://www.uihealthcare.com/topics/digestivesystem/constipation.html), although I think it is likely more useful in the USA, since the brands and doses are not necessarily the same in Canada.
Below I outline my opinions on fibre supplements. Remember that these opinions have been formed in the last week or so, and therefore I don’t have the most extensive experience, although I have thought about fibre supplements a lot lately since they were linked to my hospital release and I plan to head back to work on Monday. Also, as a researcher, it bothers me that I changed more than one variable at a time (I started using Benefibre and changed the times I took the supplements almost at the same time – which factor is most important?). However, these are just my experiences and I believe there are lots of varied personal experiences (otherwise, the doctors wouldn’t have to try things out and wait and see what happens, there would be hard and fast rules about what works).
- Metamucil orange flavoured supplement (the only type of Metamucil the hospital carries) is totally disgusting. It gets very thick and you can’t disguise the taste. Also, for anyone who has had to take Pico-Salax before a surgery or colonoscopy, the taste gave me flashbacks.
- Metamucil “wafers” (read “cookies”) actually aren’t bad. However, if you have to take the dose I was recommended (the equivalent of 2 packs of liquid 3 times a day), you have to eat 9 cookies a day, which equals 9 cookies or 540 calories of cookies. That is a lot of calories to add to your diet if you need to be concerned about those things (the resident was concerned in the long-term, though I need to gain about 10lbs right now). Also, you get sick of the cookies quickly. They do fit into my purse nicely and serve as a snack, which is positive.
- Metamucil also comes in caplet form. There was some concern about their ability to dissolve quickly enough in my short intestinal tract, but there were no problems with the dissolution. However, I had a lot of pills to take (8 pills 3 times a day) which is daunting.
- The Metamucil caused a lot of discomfort and cramping, although it did achieve the desired effect of slowing down my digestive tract (enough to get released from the hospital).
- Benefibre is so, so, so much easier to take. I have only been taking it for a couple of days, but it seems to be working well (maybe not as well as the Metamucil, but it is also not causing the cramps that Metamucil did). I have only dissolved it in liquids so far (though I’m going to try baking it into muffins later!), and it definitely dissolves better in warm liquids (the results with hot tea were much better than with cold water). In the tea, you really can’t tell the difference. In the cold water, it didn’t all dissolve, but it was still infinitely better than the Metamucil liquid. I only have to take 2 teaspoons 3 times a day, which dissolves easily in a regular cup of tea.
- I have been playing with the dosage times over the past few days. In the hospital, they gave me the Metamucil with meals. I think the logic is that it needs to mix with food. However, that was resulting in me taking all the supplements between about 8am and 6pm and then none for 14 hours. This was causing unequal results (lots of liquid during the evening and almost none during the night and day). I have since started taking the supplements at breakfast, late afternoon and bedtime and it seems to be better.
No related posts.
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.
Fibre Supplements
I started to respond to Brevin’s question about fibre supplements, but the comment was getting too long, so I figured I’d make a new post about it. I just started using fibre supplements during my last hospital stay. I hadn’t needed them before but after the incident with the blockages, I was losing way too much fluid (I had to stay in the hospital on IV), so I had to take fibre supple
ments to slow things down.
On a bit of an educational note, if you’re looking at different brands and options, I think the key is that you need a “bulking agent”. The psyllium in Metamucil is a bulking agent, as are a few synthetic fibres (like inulin in Benefibre). In general, the synthetic fibres need smaller doses to achieve the same results. I also looked into more food-like options, such as cereals with psyllium fibre. The problem is, while the nutritional information tells you how much fibre the cereal provides, it doesn’t tell you how much psyllium fibre in particular you will get from a serving. My understanding is that this matters – not all fibres do the same thing. The bulking agents actually absorb water, but other fibres don’t. There is a useful comparison chart found at the University of Iowa Hospital website (http://www.uihealthcare.com/topics/digestivesystem/constipation.html), although I think it is likely more useful in the USA, since the brands and doses are not necessarily the same in Canada.
Below I outline my opinions on fibre supplements. Remember that these opinions have been formed in the last week or so, and therefore I don’t have the most extensive experience, although I have thought about fibre supplements a lot lately since they were linked to my hospital release and I plan to head back to work on Monday. Also, as a researcher, it bothers me that I changed more than one variable at a time (I started using Benefibre and changed the times I took the supplements almost at the same time – which factor is most important?). However, these are just my experiences and I believe there are lots of varied personal experiences (otherwise, the doctors wouldn’t have to try things out and wait and see what happens, there would be hard and fast rules about what works).
- Metamucil orange flavoured supplement (the only type of Metamucil the hospital carries) is totally disgusting. It gets very thick and you can’t disguise the taste. Also, for anyone who has had to take Pico-Salax before a surgery or colonoscopy, the taste gave me flashbacks.
- Metamucil “wafers” (read “cookies”) actually aren’t bad. However, if you have to take the dose I was recommended (the equivalent of 2 packs of liquid 3 times a day), you have to eat 9 cookies a day, which equals 9 cookies or 540 calories of cookies. That is a lot of calories to add to your diet if you need to be concerned about those things (the resident was concerned in the long-term, though I need to gain about 10lbs right now). Also, you get sick of the cookies quickly. They do fit into my purse nicely and serve as a snack, which is positive.
- Metamucil also comes in caplet form. There was some concern about their ability to dissolve quickly enough in my short intestinal tract, but there were no problems with the dissolution. However, I had a lot of pills to take (8 pills 3 times a day) which is daunting.
- The Metamucil caused a lot of discomfort and cramping, although it did achieve the desired effect of slowing down my digestive tract (enough to get released from the hospital).
- Benefibre is so, so, so much easier to take. I have only been taking it for a couple of days, but it seems to be working well (maybe not as well as the Metamucil, but it is also not causing the cramps that Metamucil did). I have only dissolved it in liquids so far (though I’m going to try baking it into muffins later!), and it definitely dissolves better in warm liquids (the results with hot tea were much better than with cold water). In the tea, you really can’t tell the difference. In the cold water, it didn’t all dissolve, but it was still infinitely better than the Metamucil liquid. I only have to take 2 teaspoons 3 times a day, which dissolves easily in a regular cup of tea.
- I have been playing with the dosage times over the past few days. In the hospital, they gave me the Metamucil with meals. I think the logic is that it needs to mix with food. However, that was resulting in me taking all the supplements between about 8am and 6pm and then none for 14 hours. This was causing unequal results (lots of liquid during the evening and almost none during the night and day). I have since started taking the supplements at breakfast, late afternoon and bedtime and it seems to be better.
No related posts.
Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.