Health knowledge made personal
Join this community!
› Share page:
Search posts:

David James - Court Denies Hospital Permission to Stop Life-SustainingTreatment

Posted Dec 11 2012 10:36am
In May, 68-year-old former musician David James was admitted to a British hospital with constipation.  But he went on to develop pneumonia and became critically unwell.  He has had a stroke, resulting in damage to the brain and loss of function on his right side, and he has also had a number of cardiac arrests and suffered kidney damage.  Clinicians have diagnosed him as in a minimally conscious state.

More recently, the hospital applied to the Court of Protection for a declaration that, if James’ condition deteriorated, it need not offer him “futile and burdensome” treatment (cardiopulmonary resuscitation, renal replacement treatment, or invasive support for chronic low blood pressure). 

Mr. Justice Peter Jackson refused the hospital's declaration, stating:  “Although Mr. James’s condition is in many respects grim, I am not persuaded that treatment would be futile or overly burdensome or that there is no prospect of recovery.”  “Although the burdens of treatment are very great indeed, they have to be weighed against the benefits of a continued existence.”  He added that recovery did not mean a return to full health but the resumption of a quality of life that James himself would consider worthwhile.
Justice Jackson further observed that doctors had undervalued the limited quality of life that the patient could still enjoy. He also noted that James’s medical condition was “fluctuating,” adding that it would not be right to validate in advance the withholding of the treatments in all circumstances.  ( Liverpool Daily Trust ) (BMJ 2012; 345: e8404)
This case is not surprising.  Many cases (famously Wendland and Martin in the USA, for example) have drawn a sharp distinction between PVS and MCS patients.  Clinicians can usually establish zero quality of life, and thus best interest, to stop LSMT for a PVS patient.  But it is far tougher to do that for an MCS patient.  Even British cases have denied clinician requests to stop LSMT in which severely brain damaged children would still interact with her environment, for example, by smiling at their parents.
Post a comment
Write a comment:

Related Searches